Hostage drama seizes the imagination
© Bill Morrison, "The News & Observer Raleigh", March 7, 1997
Not all acts of bravery in wartime take place on the battlefield, as director
Sergei Bodrov suggests in "Prisoner of the Mountain," the Russian nominee for
the year's best foreign language film. Inspired by Tolstoy's "A Prisoner of the
Caucasus," this is the story of two Russian captives who are to be swapped for a
Chechen prisoner. There are brief, lethal acts of violence, but the drama here
takes place far from the killing fields. It's a remarkable movie.
Bodrov's story begins as young Russians are subjected to the rude probings and
naked embarrassment of their army physical. If all of them are understandably
nervous, most look forward to life as a soldier and the adventure they believe
lies ahead.
Their illusions are quickly shattered. There are no grand wars in their future,
no polished swords and gleaming steeds. One of the soldiers, a boy named Vania
(played by the director's son, Sergei Bodrov Jr.) finds himself assigned to an
outpost in Chechnya, the fiercely independent republic located in the rugged
Caucasus Mountains. The Chechen people have long been a thorn in Russia's side.
Even today rebels defy Russian tanks with ancient rifles and knives as sharp as
their wits.
Tolstoy had been a soldier and sided with the Russians. Bodrov, though, takes no
sides. He tells a universal tale of decades-old animosities often as arbitrary
and irrational as the battles against which they are set. As Bodrov says, "It's
easier to kill a man than to love him."
Vania, an innocent, untested in war and in life, one day finds himself on a
patrol in a distant mountain canyon. Riding next to him is the handsome young
Sacha, a seasoned soldier played with panache by Oleg Menshikov, the popular
Russian actor who starred in the Oscar-winning "Burnt by the Sun." Sacha makes
you almost believe that war is an adventure for boys who will never grow up and
certainly will never grow old.
The patrol is ambushed, cut to ribbons by guerrilla soldiers. Only Vania and
Sacha survive. They are taken prisoner and thrown across a couple of pack
animals and taken to a primitive village sitting like a slightly askew crown
atop a mountain peak. It has electricity, so the outside world has begun to
intrude and in one inspired scene the shackled men dance to Louis Armstrong's
ironically titled "What a Wonderful World."
The men have nothing in common and Sacha, at first, provides no comfort for the
frightened but trusting young boy. As their relationship develops, so does their
friendship with two residents of the village, an exquisitely beautiful little
girl and a likable old Chechen guard, a man who loved to sing before the
Russians cut his tongue out. Sacha gives him the only thing he has to give the
man, a pair of black mirror glasses with a broken lens. Vania makes a bird
puppet for the girl, who adores him.
Their captor, the dour Abdoul-Mourat, the girl's father and the patriarch of the
village, wants to swap them for his son, a prisoner of the Russians. In part to
verify that the prisoners indeed exist, the men are instructed to summon their
mothers, with the understanding that Sacha and Vania will be executed if the
women fail to appear within 10 days. Ah, but one of them is an orphan. As the
tension grows so does our affection for these unsung heroes.
Bodrov's film indicts war (as any sane man would). It's extremely well written,
richly detailed and superbly acted. Menshikov has the potential for Hollywood
stardom with his good looks and his gift for dramatic comedy. Vania has the
fresh-scrubbed appeal of a Frank Capra character, and Susanna Mekhralieva, who
plays their friend, the young girl, has an exotic beauty deserving of more
screen time.
This film ends with an image at once ironic and unforgettable. Bodrov leaves us
with the idea we are powerless to change our destiny. War is in the hands of the
gods, and we're the unwilling pawns. An ironic man, Bodrov at least has a sense
of humor.
Submitted by Anni Nikolova
|