Two Hostages In a Village So Remote
© Janet Maslin, The New York Times, January 31, 1997
The setting is exotic and beautiful, as if Sergei Bodrov's "Prisoner of the
Mountains" were a travelogue rather than a war story. In a remote Muslim
village high in the Caucasus Mountains, two Russian soldiers abruptly find
themselves taken hostage. Their captors live in pristine isolation, following
archaic customs in a place that time seems to have passed by. "The mountains
will protect us," the children sing. "The wind frightens the heart of any
stranger here."
Certainly it frightens Sacha (Oleg Menshikov), a dashing and seasoned soldier,
and Vanya (Sergei Bodrov Jr., the director's son), a brand-new recruit. These
two remain in limbo throughout most of Mr. Bodrov's strong and affecting
pacifist fable, which is based on Tolstoy's novella "Prisoner of the
Caucasus." Summoning images of Chechnya (the film was shot in nearby Dagestan),
it tells a story of irreconcilable conflict that remains all too timely 150
years after it was written.
As the two Russians get to know each other and their captors, they experience a
mixture of fascination and fear. The Muslims of the village intrigue the
soldiers, and the feeling becomes mutual; even the audience will feel its share
of curiosity, thanks to the film's acute eye for rich, mysterious detail in the
village setting. And as Mr. Bodrov's visually appealing film moves forward in a
relaxed spirit that belies its sense of danger, the reasons for fighting between
these two factions become increasingly irrelevant. But however proud and
independent they appear, this story's characters know they are only pawns in a
larger game.
Abdoul-Mourat (Jamal Sihouralidze), the village's stern leader, has a son who is
being held prisoner by Russian troops. And he considers trading Sacha and Vanya
for his son's freedom. Or else, the villagers hint darkly, these two could be
sold into slavery.
Meanwhile, the pretty little daughter of Abdoul-Mourat, a girl named Dina
(Susanna Mekhraliyeva) with the look of a dark-eyed Gypsy sprite, is eager to
flirt with her father's captives. Though very young, she seems to understand
both the prisoners' humanity and the exigencies of war.
"Prisoner of the Mountains," which opens today at Lincoln Plaza, is directed
by Mr. Bodrov with both an oddly tranquil spirit and the awareness of a
tightening noose. The juxtaposition of these incongruous moods gives the film
its quiet power. The captives' potential nightmare becomes a voyage of
discovery, up to and even beyond the point where the realities of war become
grimly clear. Mr. Bodrov allows one character's wry humor and sang-froid to
sustain him even beyond the grave.
Mr. Menshikov, seen in Nikita Mikhalkov's "Burnt by the Sun," cuts a dashing
figure and adds drama to the two soldiers' complicated friendship. In his more
ingenuous way, the younger Mr. Bodrov is just as good. Mr. Bodrov makes an
affecting debut thanks to his father, who let him take a break from a graduate
dissertation on Renaissance art to play this role. The other players, who are
nonprofessional actors, perform with the same simple grace.
Submitted by Anni Nikolova
|